Our Final Pizza Ranking

I think the question that we get asked most when we tell people about this year’s travels is “What is your favorite pizza place?”. This is a great question, particularly because we have a lot of favorites. We have a favorite deep dish, a favorite NY style, and a favorite thin crust. We have our favorite unusual topping combination and our favorite Neapolitan traditional Margherita pie.

Now that we have been to all 101 pizzas on the list from the Daily Meal, we have attempted to rank them from #1 to #101 ourselves. You will notice that our ranking differs substantially from the Daily Meal’s ranking, and I should say that this obviously reflects our personal pizza tastes and opinions and (almost) all of the pizzas on the list deserved to be there. We also each made our own ranking so we weren’t influenced by each other’s choices, and there are definitely some that we disagreed on.

(If you aren’t interested in our whole ranking, feel free to skip down to the bottom of the list, where we discuss the highlights and summarize.)

                DAILY MEAL                                      BARBARA                                    ERIC

  1. Pepe’s Pizza, New Haven                   Pepe’s Pizza                              Pepe’s Pizza
  2. Di Fara, Brooklyn                                 Pizzeria Beddia                        Pizzeria Beddia
  3. Roberta’s, Brooklyn                            Di Fara                                       BAR
  4. Mozza, Los Angeles                             BAR                                            Emily
  5. Sally’s Apizza, New Haven                 Lucali                                         Mozza
  6. Flour+Water, San Francisco              Emily                                          Di Fara
  7. Louie and Ernie’s, Bronx                   Johns of Bleecker                     Sally’s
  8. Buddy’s Pizza, Detroit                       Totonno’s                                  Grimaldi’s
  9. Coalfire Pizza, Chicago                      Grimaldi’s                                  Apizza Scholls
  10. Joe’s, NYC                                             Coalfire Pizza                            Pizza Moto
  11. Pizzeria Bianco, Phoenix                  Roberta’s                                   Roberta’s
  12. Papa’s Tomato Pies, NJ                     Sally’s                                         Ernesto’s
  13. Modern Apizza, New Haven             Apizza Scholls                           Lucali
  14. Totonno’s, Brooklyn                          Mozza                                        Hog & Hominy
  15. Pequod’s, Chicago                              Pizza Moto                                Una Pizza Napoletana
  16. Patsy’s, NYC                                        Co.                                              Coalfire Pizza
  17. Gino’s East, Chicago                          Gjelina                                       Osteria
  18. Co., NYC                                                Sotto                                          Totonno’s
  19. Motorino, NYC                                    Pizzeria Regina                         Kesté
  20. Tony’s Pizza Napoletana, SF           Pequod’s                                   Pete’s New Haven Apizza      
  21. Paulie Gee’s, Brooklyn                      Patsy’s                                        Sotto
  22. Johns of Bleecker, NYC                     Antico                                        Pequod’s
  23. Grimaldi’s, Brooklyn                          Ernie’s Pizzeria                         Margot’s Pizza
  24. Kesté, NYC                                           Pizzeria Bianco                         Tacconelli’s Original Pizza
  25. Lou Malnati’s, Chicago                     Cheeseboard                            Pizzeria Vetri
  26. Antico Pizza, Atlanta                         Lorenzo and Sons                    Johns of Bleecker
  27. Apizza Scholls, Portland                   Kesté                                          Cheeseboard
  28. Lucali, Brooklyn                                  Roseland Apizza                       Pizza Rock
  29. Una Pizza Napoletana, SF               Tacconelli’s Original Pizza       Umberto’s
  30. Lombardi’s, NYC                                Una Pizza Napoletana             Galleria Umberto
  31. Lorenzo and Sons, Philadelphia     Flour+Water                              Buddy’s Pizza
  32. Al Forno, Providence                         Double Mountain Brewery     Micucci’s Grocery
  33. 2Amys, Washington DC                     Osteria                                       Ernie’s Pizza
  34. Pizzeria Delfina, SF                           Umberto’s                                 Star Tavern
  35. Denino’s, Staten Island                     Paulie Gee’s                               Co.
  36. Santarpio’s, Boston                          Hog & Hominy                           Tony’s Place
  37. Umberto’s, New Hyde Park, NY      Motorino                                    Ghigiarelli’s
  38. Pete’s New Haven, Wash. DC         Otto                                             Joe’s
  39. Delorenzo’s, NJ                                  Ernesto’s                                     Antico
  40. Gjelina, Los Angeles                          Louie and Ernie’s                      Modern Apizza                       
  41. Rubirosa, NYC                                    Buddy’s Pizza                             Tony’s Pizza Napoletana
  42. Emily, Brooklyn                                  Micucci’s Grocery                      Pizzaiolo
  43. Sotto, Los Angeles                             2Amys                                          Gjelina
  44. Pizza Domenica, New Orleans       Home Slice Pizza                        Pizza Domenica
  45. Varasano’s, Atlanta                          Modern Apizza                            Amore Pizza
  46. Serious Pie, Seattle                           Pete’s New Haven Apizza         Pi Pizzeria
  47. Providence Coal Fired, Providence  Tony’s Pizza Napoletana       Pizzeria Regina
  48. Galleria Umberto, Boston              Harry’s                                         Lorenzo and Sons
  49. Harry’s Pizzeria, Miami                   Pizzeria Lola                                Brooklyn’s Pizza
  50. Pizzeria Paradiso, Wash. DC          Area 4                                           Pizzeria Bianco
  51. Colony Grill, Stamford, CT              Tony’s Place                                Pizzeria Lola
  52. Pizzeria Regina, Boston                  Santarpio’s                                  Flour+Water
  53. Gino’s of Long Beach, NY               Pizzeria Delfina                          Motorino
  54. Cheeseboard, Berkeley, CA            Pizza Rock                                    Lee’s Tavern
  55. Coppa, Boston                                   Serious Pie                                  Double Mountain Brewery
  56. Lee’s Tavern, Staten Island             Joe’s                                             Lou Malnati’s
  57. Zuppardi’s, West Haven, CT            Star Tavern                                 Harry’s
  58. Matchbox, Washington DC             Lou Malnati’s                              Zuppardi’s
  59. Hog & Hominy, Memphis                Lombardi’s                                 Pizzeria Uno
  60. Pizzeria Lola, Minneapolis              Pizzeria Vetri                              Matchbox
  61. BAR, New Haven                                Varasano’s                                 Rubirosa
  62. Pizzaiolo, Oakland, CA                      New Park Pizza                         Pizzeria Delfina
  63. Tacconelli’s, Philadelphia                Galleria Umberto                      Otto
  64. Ken’s Artisan Pizza, Portland, OR  Pizza Man                                   Roseland Apizza
  65. Home Slice Pizza, Austin, TX           Pi Pizzeria                                   Pizza Man
  66. Osteria, Philadelphia                        Providence Coal Fired              Serious Pie
  67. Domenick & Pias, Waterbury, CT   Pizzeria Paradiso                      Area 4
  68. Pizzeria Uno, Chicago                       Piece                                           Louie and Ernie’s
  69. Double Mountain Brewery, OR     Amore Pizza                              Paulie Gee’s
  70. Barone’s, Los Angeles                       The Backspace                          The Backspace
  71. Metro Pizza, Las Vegas                     Zuppardi’s                                  Providence Coal Fired
  72. Brooklyn’s Pizza, Hackensack, NJ   Rubirosa                                     Gino’s East
  73. Pizza Rock, Las Vegas                        Delorenzo’s Tomato Pies        Zaffiro’s
  74. Ernesto’s, Boston                               Brooklyn’s Pizza                        2Amys
  75. Ernie’s Pizzeria, New Haven            Cane Rosso                               Piece
  76. Area 4, Cambridge, MA                     Matchbox                                  Tarry Lodge
  77. Pizza Moto, Brooklyn                        Pizzeria Uno                              Lombardi’s
  78. Amore Pizza, Queens                        Ken’s Artisan Pizza                   Colony Grill
  79. Punch Neapolitan, St. Paul, MN     Artichoke Basille                      Santarpio’s
  80. Otto Pizza, Portland, ME                   Pizza Delicious                         Home Slice Pizza
  81. Pi Pizzeria, St. Louis                           Al Forno                                     Pizza Delicious
  82. Star Tavern, Orange, NJ                    Pizzeria Domenica                   Gino’s of Long Beach
  83. Pizzeria Beddia, Philadelphia          Gino’s of Long Beach               Patsy’s
  84. Roseland Apizza,  Derby, CT            Denino’s                                    Punch Neapolitan Pizzeria
  85. Sal’s Pizza, Mamaroneck, NY            Margot’s Pizza                          Al Forno
  86. Margot’s Pizza, Brooklyn                  Colony Grill                               Varasano’s
  87. New Park Pizza, Queens                  Tarry Lodge                               Pizzeria Locale
  88. Pizzeria Vetri, Philadelphia              Pizzaiolo                                     Delorenzo’s Tomato Pies
  89. Tarry Lodge, Port Chester, NY         Coppa                                        Ken’s Artisan Pizza
  90. Pizza Man, Milwaukee                       Punch Neapolitan Pizza          New Park Pizza
  91. Zaffiro’s, Milwaukee                           Zaffiro’s                                     Sal’s Pizza
  92. Cane Rosso, Dallas, TX                       Gino’s East                                Pizzeria Paradiso
  93. The Backspace, Austin, TX                Pizzeria Locale                          Cane Rosso
  94. Pizza Delicious, New Orleans           Metro Pizza                               Artichoke Basille
  95. Pizzeria Locale, Denver                     Sal’s Pizza                                  Coppa
  96. Micucci’s Grocery, Portland, ME     Ghigiarelli’s                                Denino’s
  97. Tony’s Place, Philadelphia                Domenick & Pia’s                      Metro Pizza
  98. Artichoke Basille, NYC                      Lee’s Tavern                              Domenick & Pia’s
  99. Piece, Chicago                                      800 Degrees                              800 Degrees
  100. 800 Degrees, Los Angeles                  Papa’s Tomato Pie                   Papa’s Tomato Pie
  101. Ghigiarelli’s, Old Forge, PA               Barone’s Famous Italian          Barone’s Famous Italian

 

Our top 20 are pretty similar to each other’s. Pepe’s tops all three lists, with the Brooklyn pizzerias Di Fara, Roberta’s, Lucali, Grimaldi’s, Totonno’s all highly ranked. Coalfire Pizza in Chicago was obviously very high on our lists, as was Mozza in Los Angeles and Apizza Scholls in Portland. Major differences here between our lists and the list from the Daily Meal are Pizza Moto (also in Brooklyn, ranked high on our list but low on the Daily Meal’s) and Pizzeria Beddia in Philadelphia (we ranked this #2, it was that good!). We also both preferred the pizza at BAR to the pizza at Sally’s and Modern in New Haven, although we realize that Sally’s has its dedicated fans, being a much older establishment. (Photos below are from our top three of Pepe’s, Di Fara, and Pizzeria Beddia)

img-20161113-wa0002

The next 20 places we start to disagree a bit more. The rest of the places that the Daily Meal had in their top 20 fall into our top 40, for the most part. Some of their higher-ranked places (like Louie and Ernie’s in NYC, Flour + Water in San Francisco, and Buddy’s Pizza in Detroit) we liked too, but we couldn’t rank them in our top 20. We both agreed with the Daily Meal that Pequod’s had the best deep dish in Chicago.

img_20160302_181858757   img_20160319_173747599

We then get to the middle of the pack at numbers 40-60. The Cheeseboard in Berkeley ranked right in the middle according to the Daily Meal, but we both have this up higher. Same with Hog & Hominy in Memphis, Emily in Brooklyn, and Sotto in LA. The Daily Meal also had a few ranked in this set that we put much farther down on our own lists, like Coppa in Boston, and Rubirosa in NYC. We’ve also got our second favorite deep dish here (Lou Malnati’s), although the Daily Meal listed this one much higher.

From numbers 60-80, the lists start to get tricky. These are the places that we really liked, but they didn’t thrill us. We wouldn’t say any of them were bad, and we’d definitely go to them all again. For whatever reason, we didn’t find them super special. Again, we put a few of the Daily Meal’s low ranked pizzas higher on our own lists, like Ernie’s in New Haven (can’t believe we had never been here before!) and both Osteria and Tacconelli’s in Philadelphia.

And finally, the end of the lists. As we said before, we didn’t HATE any of these pizzas. We can see why they all made it on to the list, and they all have the Yelp reviews to prove that they belong there. However, the bottom of our bunch consisted of Domenick & Pias in Waterbury, CT, Papa’s Tomato Pie in Robbinsville, NJ, 800 Degrees in Los Angeles, and Barone’s Famous Italian Restaurant, also in LA. If we ever go back to LA, these last two would not be places that we stopped at again, especially since LA also has Mozza and Sotto right downtown. (Photos from 800 Degrees and Papa’s Tomato Pies. Barone’s pizza looked too unappetizing to even add to this post).

img_20160417_155918987     img_20151127_180512665

Margot’s is also low on the Daily Meal’s list, and Barb’s as well, but mainly got deductions because it was so hard to get to. You’ll see on Eric’s list that it is much higher ranked, because the pizza was very good. Another place that is low on the Daily Meal list here, but we thought was highly underrated, is Micucci’s Grocery in Portland, Maine. We’d stop there again for slices.

Now, we want your suggestions! Where should we go next?

 

Published by

5 thoughts on “Our Final Pizza Ranking

  1. Oh my god. I love you guys. I’d love to interview you about your pizza questing for my pizza site best-pizza.nyc. Could be fun to go grab a slice somewhere. If you’ve read these 101s maybe you’ll recognize my name 🙂

    1. We’d love to grab a slice with you! We absolutely recognize your name (also because we just read your NYT article on Sofia’s new pizza – we were just there about 2 weeks ago and had no idea what was going on behind the scenes!). We are huge fans of your lists, obviously 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

four × 2 =